TL;DR
Get movie nights delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Guillermo Rodriguez, Jimmy Kimmel’s longtime sidekick, has become an unexpected fan favorite on the current season of Dancing With the Stars alongside partner Witney Carson. A Psychology Today analysis suggests that underdog appeal and “basking in reflected glory” may help explain why viewers continue to support him despite low judges’ scores. The season’s eventual outcome—and how much fan voting is driving his progress—remains unknown.
Guillermo Rodriguez, Jimmy Kimmel’s longtime sidekick, is emerging as an unexpected fan favorite on the current season of Dancing With the Stars, with viewers voting to keep him and professional partner Witney Carson in the competition despite low judges’ scores. A Psychology Today analysis points to his underdog appeal and a social psychology concept called “basking in reflected glory” as possible reasons for the support, while the competition’s eventual outcome remains open.
Rodriguez became known to television audiences as a quirky security guard who went on to appear as a sidekick on Jimmy Kimmel’s show. The Psychology Today analysis argues that his existing audience, informal manner and willingness to acknowledge his limitations may be contributing to his popularity on the dance competition. It describes viewers as responding to his lack of pretense and apparent authenticity, rather than only to his performance skill.
That contrast was visible after a samba with Carson received 13 out of 30 from the judges. Despite the low score, the analysis reports that enough viewers voted for the pair to return for another episode. After a dance, Rodriguez also opened his shirt to reveal the words “Dancing 4 The People”, a gesture the analysis interprets as crediting fans’ enthusiasm rather than claiming strong dance ability.
The piece describes “basking in reflected glory,” or BIRG, as one possible explanation for why people take pleasure in the success of someone they support. Social psychologist Robert Cialdini and colleagues introduced the term in a 1976 study. The analysis says fans can feel a vicarious boost when a favored person or team succeeds; it does not establish that BIRG is the sole reason viewers are voting for Rodriguez, or measure how much it affects the show’s results.
Fan Votes Challenge Judges’ Scores
The gap between Rodriguez’s judges’ score and continued progress highlights the different roles that technical evaluation and audience voting can play in a televised competition. For viewers, his run is a reminder that entertainment contests reward more than performance technique: personality, familiarity and an underdog narrative can also draw support.
The Psychology Today analysis gives readers a framework for thinking about that response without treating fan enthusiasm as proof of a single psychological motive. Its discussion of BIRG connects support for a popular contestant to a broader idea: people may feel closer to success when they identify with someone who is winning. In this case, that remains an interpretation of the response, not a finding that explains every vote.
Dancing With the Stars fan voting app
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
From Kimmel Sidekick to Contestant
Rodriguez’s television profile predates his appearance on Dancing With the Stars. He gained recognition as an onstage sidekick after starting out as a security guard associated with Jimmy Kimmel’s show. The analysis says fans’ familiarity with him may help account for his reception on the dance floor, where he is competing alongside professional dancer Witney Carson.
The concept of basking in reflected glory comes from research published in 1976 by Robert Cialdini and colleagues. A later 1986 study by C.R. Snyder, M. Lassegard and C.E. Ford examined the related idea of distancing oneself from failure, described as “cutting off reflected failure,” or CORFing. The Psychology Today article applies these concepts to fan identification; those studies are background to its interpretation, not direct evidence about the motivations of this season’s voters.
The article also notes a possible downside to strong identification with a favorite. If fans share in a contestant’s perceived success, they may also feel disappointment when that person loses. It describes concerns among some fans of other contestants and cites online criticism of Rodriguez’s dancing. Such reactions show that support for one participant can coexist with disagreement about how the competition is unfolding.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
What Drives Each Fan Vote
The available account does not give vote totals, a comparison with other contestants’ support, or evidence showing how many viewers are motivated by BIRG. It is therefore not possible to determine how much of Rodriguez’s continued run is due to that phenomenon rather than his existing audience, personal appeal, dance performances or other factors.
The analysis reports that viewers have alleged the show is rigged, but supplies no evidence that the competition has been manipulated. Those comments are unverified accusations, not confirmation of wrongdoing. It also remains unclear how far Rodriguez and Carson will advance, whether the judges’ assessments will change, and whether the audience’s support will last.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
The Next Results and Performances
Rodriguez and Carson are due to return for the next stage described in the analysis. Their subsequent performances and results will show whether fan voting continues to keep them in the competition, but no final outcome is provided. Viewers will also be able to see whether the gap between judges’ scores and audience support persists.
For now, the central development is Rodriguez’s continued presence despite a low score for the samba. Whether that run reaches the season’s final or the mirror-ball trophy is not yet known; the Psychology Today analysis frames the possibility as an open question, not a prediction.
dance competition fan support merchandise
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Key Questions
Why has Guillermo Rodriguez become a fan favorite on Dancing With the Stars?
The Psychology Today analysis points to his underdog appeal, existing audience from Jimmy Kimmel’s show, and perceived lack of pretense. It also offers BIRG as one possible explanation, not a proven account of individual votes.
What does “basking in reflected glory” mean?
BIRG describes the pleasure people may feel when someone they identify with succeeds, even though they did not contribute to that success. Robert Cialdini and colleagues introduced the term in a 1976 study.
How did Rodriguez score on the samba discussed in the analysis?
The analysis reports that judges gave Rodriguez and Witney Carson 13 out of 30 for the samba. It says the pair received enough viewer votes to return.
Has Dancing With the Stars been shown to be rigged?
No evidence of rigging is provided in the account. It mentions accusations made by viewers online, which remain unverified claims.
Will Guillermo Rodriguez win the competition?
The outcome is unknown. The analysis reports that Rodriguez and Carson remained in the competition at the time covered, but does not give the season’s final results.
Source: psychologytoday.com
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
